Vote observers cast doubt over Zimbabwe election credibility

Foreign poll observers have said Zimbabwe's presidential and legislative elections failed to conform to regional and international standards, placing in doubt the credibility of the tense vote.

Regional and international observers listed concerns over the canning of opposition rallies, denial of accreditation to several foreign media, missing voters' names from the roll at their polling station, biased state media and voter intimidation among the issues that sullied the election.

The head of the European Union observer mission, Fabio Massimo Castaldo, said on Friday the election "fell short of many regional and international standards".

"Violence and intimidation resulted ultimately in a climate of fear," he said.

Commonwealth observer mission chair Amina Mohamed, of Kenya, said overall, the voting process was "well conducted and peaceful," but a "number of significant issues" impacted the election's "credibility" and "transparency".

"Some aspects of the... election fell short of the requirements of the constitution of Zimbabwe, the electoral act and the SADC principles and guidelines governing democratic elections," said the head of the regional bloc's delegation Nevers Mumba, a former Zambian vice president.

It was a rare rebuke from the 16-nation Southern African Development Community (SADC), whose observers usually endorse polls in the member countries.

The ruling ZANU-PF party reacted angrily, dismissing the findings from Western countries as "sanctimonious notions" coming from former colonial powers with no right to teach democracy to Zimbabwe.

"We are dismissive of the rumblings, the mouthing of Nevers Mumba," party spokesperson Christopher Mutsvangwa told a press conference in Harare, describing the head of the SADC mission as a biased "preacher".

"We can't be perfect. But there is definitely no ill will in our imperfections," he said of the voting process.

Fundamental flaws

The election is being watched across southern Africa as a test of support for 80-year-old President Emmerson Mnangagwa's ZANU-PF, whose 43-year rule has been battered by a moribund economy and charges of authoritarianism.

Voting was forced to stretch into an unprecedented second day over delays in the printing of ballot papers in some key districts, including in the opposition stronghold Harare.

According to a preliminary tally shown by state broadcaster ZBC on Friday evening, ZANU-PF was leading in the parliamentary race, having secured 125 of the 210 seats up for grabs under a first-past-the-post system, against 59 for the largest opposition Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC).

Another 60 seats are appointed through a party-list system of proportional representation.

The CCC, which had more than 100 of its campaign meetings banned, lashed the electoral process as "fundamentally flawed". Less than a quarter of polling stations in Harare – an opposition stronghold – opened on time on Wednesday, the first day of voting.

The problems forced Mnangagwa, who is seeking a second term, to issue a late-night directive extending the vote by another day.

Election authorities said they were still confident of announcing the final results before the Tuesday deadline.

'Grave concern'

CCC leader Nelson Chamisa slammed the delays as "a clear case of voter suppression, a classic case of Stone Age... rigging".

Chamisa, 45, is the main challenger to Mnangagwa, 80, who came to power after a coup that deposed late ruler Robert Mugabe in 2017.

Meanwhile, 41 local monitors were arrested late at night on election day and had their computers and mobile phones confiscated by police who alleged the equipment was "used to unlawfully tabulate" results from polling stations, describing the activity as "subversive and criminal".

Most of those arrested, mainly women and men in their 20s and early 30s who work for pro-democracy NGOs, arrived Friday at a Harare court crammed into the back of an open white truck to appear before a magistrate.

"Police heavily armed with AK-47 rifles, truncheons and other assortments of weapons swooped on the accused and arrested them in a dragnet style," defence lawyer Alec Muchadehama told the judge, who set bail at $200.

The arrests add "to our grave concerns", said the EU polls observer chief.

"At this stage, it's all pointing towards a disputed election," said Kealeboga Maphunye, an African studies professor at the University of South Africa, in an online debate organised Friday by the South Africa-based Southern African Liaison Office.