How the world's top court will decide if Myanmar committed genocide against Rohingya
WORLD
4 min read
How the world's top court will decide if Myanmar committed genocide against RohingyaA ruling by ICJ on Myanmar's treatment of Rohingya could shape a genocide case against Israel over Gaza, testing how courts establish intent and weigh evidence of a campaign to destroy a group.
ICJ has never found a state responsible for committing genocide, and its Rohingya ruling could shape the case against Israel. / Reuters Archive

The United Nations' top court, the International Court of Justice, will rule on Thursday in a case in which Gambia accuses Myanmar of committing genocide against its Rohingya Muslim minority in 2017.

For the Rohingya, the judgment holds the promise of recognition and a step towards accountability.

Its reach could extend to Gaza, clarifying how courts prove the intent to destroy a people and shaping South Africa’s genocide case against Israel.

However, genocide is notoriously difficult to prove. Here are some key points ahead of the ruling.

What makes a crime genocide?

Genocide has a strict legal definition and has rarely been proven in court since it was cemented in humanitarian law. The 1948 Genocide Convention defines genocide as crimes committed "with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such".

Five criminal acts can constitute genocide: killing members of the group, causing them serious bodily or mental harm, creating conditions calculated to destroy them, preventing births, or forcibly transferring children to other groups.

International courts have established genocide in only a handful of cases since the Holocaust, including the slaughter in Cambodia of minority Cham and Vietnamese under Khmer Rouge rule in the 1970s, during which some 1.7 million people died; the 1994 mass killing of Tutsis in Rwanda; and the 1995 Srebrenica massacre of about 8,000 Muslim men and boys in Bosnia.

The challenge of proving intent

To determine that a state or individuals committed genocide, a court must find that at least one out of the five underlying criminal acts took place and that the victims were part of a distinct national, ethnic, racial or religious group.

Genocide is harder to prove than war crimes and crimes against humanity because it requires evidence of specific intent.

That intent can be established through direct statements or orders, but may also be inferred from a pattern of conduct.

Where courts have found genocide

The ICJ has issued judgments in two previous genocide cases, both stemming from the 1990s Balkan wars that followed the collapse of Yugoslavia.

In 2007, it found that Serbia did not commit genocide but did violate the Genocide Convention by failing to prevent or punish genocide committed by Bosnian Serb troops in Srebrenica.

In 2015, it found genocide had not been committed in Croatia.

UN tribunals convicted dozens of perpetrators of genocide in Rwanda and Bosnia.

In 2018, a hybrid UN-Cambodian tribunal found two leaders of Cambodia's Khmer Rouge guilty of genocide, following years of debate about whether the "Killing Fields" constituted genocide.

The case against Myanmar

Myanmar's 2017 military crackdown drove more than 730,000 Rohingya Muslims into Bangladesh amid allegations of killings, rape and arson.

Witnesses told the court they saw mass killings, rapes and homes being burned.

UN investigations into both Myanmar's treatment of the Rohingya and Israel's conduct in Gaza said acts they described as genocidal had occurred.

Both countries dispute the legal significance of those findings. Thursday's ruling will show how the ICJ weighs conclusions from UN fact-finding reports.

RelatedTRT World - ICJ grants Israel another extension to respond in genocide case brought by South Africa

What Myanmar ruling could mean for Gaza

In 2023, South Africa filed a case at the ICJ accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza.

While a final ruling in that case is not expected before 2029, legal experts say they will closely watch how the court rules in the Myanmar case.

The Myanmar judgment will also look more closely at how a pattern of actions can show an intent to commit genocide.

Gambia and several intervening states have urged judges to look beyond mass killing and also consider sexual violence, forced displacement and harm to children as indicators of genocidal intent.

Myanmar says its operations targeted an insurgency rather than the Rohingya as a group. Israel similarly says its military campaign is directed at Hamas militants, not Palestinians.

RelatedTRT World - 'Most comprehensive genocide case ever': The Gambia presses Myanmar at ICJ
SOURCE:TRT World and Agencies