Israeli troops killed hostages after ignoring call for help, probe finds

The three Israeli hostages were shot dead in a Gaza building though they were waving a white flag and shouting for help in Hebrew.

Hearing cries of "help!" and "they're shooting at me", Israeli commanders asked the surviving hostage to advance towards the soldiers. / Photo: AFP
AFP

Hearing cries of "help!" and "they're shooting at me", Israeli commanders asked the surviving hostage to advance towards the soldiers. / Photo: AFP

Israeli soldiers ignored cries for "help" when they stormed a Gaza building holding three hostages just days before killing them by mistake, a military investigation has said.

The soldiers also heard "hostages" shouted in Hebrew on December 10, but interpreted that as a "terrorist deception attempt" by Hamas fighters to lure them into the building in the Gaza district of Shejaiya, the probe said on Thursday.

Believing the building was rigged with explosives, the soldiers exited and killed five Hamas fighters trying to escape, it added.

The hostages then probably fled the building also, and on December 15, Israeli soldiers shot them after mistakenly identifying them as a threat, the investigation said.

Two were killed instantly. The third hostage fled and soldiers were ordered to hold fire in order to identify him, the probe said.

Hearing cries of "help!" and "they're shooting at me", Israeli commanders asked the surviving hostage to advance towards the soldiers.

But two soldiers "who did not hear the order" because of "noise" from a nearby tank shot him dead.

Read More
Read More

Resistance groups reject truce, swap deal until Israel stops war on Gaza

Loading...

'Could have been prevented'

The three hostages were all shirtless and one had been carrying a white flag.

On December 14, an army drone had identified signs of "SOS" and "help, three hostages" on a building close to where the three hostages were shot.

The army "failed in its mission to rescue the hostages in this event," army chief Herzi Halevi said in a statement published along with the report of the investigation.

The three fatalities "could have been prevented", he added. Soon after the killings of the hostages were announced.

Israel has been mourning the deaths of the hostages identified as Yotam Haim, Alon Shamriz and Samer El Talalqa.

The killings of the three men, all in their twenties, have sparked protests in Tel Aviv, where demonstrators demanded that the authorities come up with a new plan to bring home the remaining 129 hostages still held in Gaza.

About 250 people were taken hostage during Hamas's October 7 attacks in Israel, which resulted in the deaths of around 1,140 people based on Israeli figures.

Israel launched a massive military offensive against Gaza that has left much of the enclave in ruins.

Officials in Gaza say the Israeli attacks have killed at least 21,320 people, mostly women and children.

Read More
Read More

UN reports rapid deterioration of Palestinian rights in occupied West Bank

Route 6